top of page

Frankenstein by Mary Shelley (1818 version)

Writer: Kathy Miller
Kathy Miller
Dec 18, 2021
2 min read

Date read: 12/18/21

So first off, I'm not sure how long this took me to read, because my husband finished the first draft of one of his novels and I read that also while I was reading this.


Also, a woman is killed in this novel but I am not adding it to the Violence Against Women counter because of several reasons: she wasn't killed because she was a woman, but to hurt someone else; her death was pertinent to the story and not just for it's own sake like in The Bend in the River; and finally, because the actual violence isn't depicted in the novel.


Now, to my assessment of Frankenstein, one of the most famous novels of all time. Frankly...it was kinda boring. I'm sure this was a page turner in 1818 when Shelley wrote it. Other novels of the time like The Legend of Sleepy Hollow were also frightening in similar ways. But in 2021, it was kinda bleh. Long periods of very flowery dialog and the ending is very anticlimactic.


In essence, this entire story can be summed up with "that escalated quickly". Victor Frankenstein, a Mary Sue character who can do amazing things no one else can do, decides to reanimate a corpse. Or, rather, a body made of corpse pieces. Unlike in the movie versions, there is no "It's alive, alive!!!" or lightening. In fact, the whole making of the monster is blink-and-you-miss-it. It happens very quickly and basically off-stage. You don't see it. Then, after making this monster, Victor...goes and takes a nap.


I suspect parts of this were an allegory of the book of Genesis. Given when it was written I can see where you'd want to be very circumspect about Biblical criticism. At any rate, the majority of the novel is Victor refusing to take responsibility for what he's done and take any action to fix the situation. And he ends up alone.


Given this was an early version of the horror genre, I can see where a lot of tropes we recognize now as cliches got their start.


All in all, it was an old novel that does not now carry the punch it did then.


Rereadable: probably not

Time to Read: Unsure - a few days; the version I borrowed from the library was half this novel, and half a bunch of commentary on the novel (like literally the second half of the book was commentary, which I did not read, because I wanted to form my own opinion).

Classic: Yes, if only because it was one of the first novels of this kind. Also because Mary Shelley was bad ass.



Recent Posts

See All
Life After Life

Kate Atkinson, 2013 Date read: 11/9/26 I really enjoyed this novel. It has made me think, in the same way Everything, Everywhere, All At Once made me think. How many different paths can one life take?

 
 
 
Effi Briest

Theodor Fontane, 1895 Date read: 10/31/26 🎃 This is Madame Bovary or Anna Karenina all over again. Same sort story again. Young woman marries an older man, cheats on him, dies dramatically. This one

 
 
 
The Power and the Glory

Graham Greene, 1940 date read: 10/27/26 First impression: Mexican Les Mis? Yes, actually. It is the same basic premise: dedicated police officer seeking a prisoner. Except the prisoner in this is a C

 
 
 

Comments


Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

©2021 by Lengthy Literary List. Proudly created with Wix.com

  • Instagram
bottom of page